A muse on tonight’s talk at the State Library of NSW entitled ‘Sleeping Beauties’, featuring Jane Gleeson-White and Geordie Williamson. Presented in conjunction with the Stella Literary Prize, there was a lively discussion of several Australian women authors who deserve a wider audience for their work. There couldn’t be two better-placed people to discuss the topic than Jane, blogger at Bookish Girl and author of the very accessible Australian Classics (see my review here), and Geordie, chief literary critic at The Australian and author of the recently published The Burning Library.
Jane aptly started off proceedings by declaring 2012 the year of the woman writer in Australia, with so many awards won by the likes of Anna Funder and Gillian Mears (see my review of Foal’s Bread here). The subsequent discussion touched on the issues of the imbalance of women-to-men in publication and reviewing statistics, and how even some of the published women’s stories in the twentieth century were edited by men for a particular assumed audience, during which the essence or flow had been excised and the story sadly depleted. As a bit of an idealist, I just find this sort of bias mind-bending and terribly sad. Anyway, we soon dived into a discussion of the following authors and their works:
- Barbara Baynton: short stories, particularly, as Jane noted, the ‘chilling’ The Broken Vessel.
- Judith Wright: how her second intimate poetry collection ‘Woman to Man’ was not published because it was considered ‘too obstetric’.
- M Barnard Eldershaw: this was one of Geordie’s picks… or should I say two? -for, as Geordie explained, MBE was actually two women: Marjorie Barnard and Flora Eldershaw. Both highly intelligent, Geordie explained the cruel curtailing of Barnard’s dreams of taking up a place she won at Oxford by her father. She said, ‘Life is backed up in me for miles and miles’, such a heart-rending expression. Their novel A House is Built was discussed. Set in 1830s Sydney, it is the story of a successful early merchant – and sounds just up my street – expect a review of this soon(ish!). Other works include Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow. Geordie described how these women authors worked within the masculine rule book of publication, but did so with a very feminine focus as well as a subversive (and therefore much more interesting) streak. They were hugely influential on a certain Patrick White, too. And it wasn’t just their fiction, for they also wrote a lot of critical work, including reviews of the young Christina Stead. Marjorie Barnard went on to write solo; her works include The Persimmon Tree and Other Stories.
- Henry Handel Richardson: Jane commented that HHR’s Maurice Guest is perhaps her favourite novel by an Australian author (to which she quickly added Voss and Carpentaria!). Her debut novel, it is, in Jane’s words, an ‘overblown, passionate, Wagnerian story. Set in Leipzig, it centres on a love triangle, with poor Maurice the hapless dupe who’s in love with the gifted music student, Louise Dufrayer. For Jane, it shines every bit if not more than HHR’s more recognised ‘Australian’ works The Getting of Wisdom and The Fortunes of Richard Mahony.
- Christina Stead: Geordie said the neglect shown to HHR’s Maurice Guest applies to all of Christina Stead’s work – cue much nodding of knowledgeable heads in the audience! Jonathan Franzen is not the first to acknowledge Stead as one of the great twentieth century novelists, said Geordie. Many other critics and authors have said much the same thing. Yet still Stead sits in the shadows: she sold 199-odd books in 2008 and was only taught in one Australian University. Why? Is it because of her ‘intelligent ferocity’ an approach she had to life and to writing? Is it because ‘we like our modernism light and our Booker Prize novels well edited? Jane agreed that Stead can be difficult, admitting it had taken her a few attempts to get through The Man who Loved Children, but now adores her. Other titles of Stead’s mentioned included For Love Alone and The Salzburg Tales, a book of short stories.
- Oodgeroo Noonuccal’s poetry, and how the Indigenous voices are starting to pick up the stories written in our landscape, by writers such as Alexis Wright (see my review of Carpentaria here) and Kim Scott (see my review of That Deadman Dance here).
- Amy Witting: the first Aussie to sell two stories to The New Yorker, a writer whom Barry Oakley called ‘the Australian Chekhov’, and yet she is not even mentioned in the Macquarie Pen Anthology of Australian authors and her works are all out of print. Her works include I for Isobel, which Lisa at ANZ Lit Lovers has reviewed here.
- Exiles at Home by Drusilla Modjeska was also mentioned as a great way into this world of neglected Australian female authors.
An hour well spent!
It was a shame there weren’t more literature lovers in the audience this evening. I hope there’s a similar session at next year’s Sydney Writers’ Festival, as the topic deserves as wide an audience as the female writers discussed.
In the meantime, there’s so many Australian women authors demanding my attention, it’s hard to know where to start…
Happy reading…
It sounds like the sort of session I’d have attended if it had been in Melbourne, what a treat.
How interesting that Jane thinks of Maurice Guest as an Aussie novel, because while I often recommend The Fortunes of Richard Mahoney as a great Australian novel, I’ve never thought of Maurice Guest as ‘Australian’ at all (even though Louise is an Australian expat). It’s a wonderful novel of obsession set in Austria – a city obsessed by music. My review is here: http://wp.me/phTIP-Ov but I’d love to read a review by Jane that explains her PoV).
Oh Lisa, sorry, I think that’s my fault. I should have written favourite novel by Australian author, rather than ‘Aussie novel’. She did discuss the plot, which as you say, is set o/s, and also the publication of it. Perhaps I should have quoted Carmen Callil, writing a review of it in the Guardian on its centenary in 2008, who wrote: ‘It belongs to so many countries, and so many cultures and traditions, that it sits easily nowhere except in one quarter: as an unequalled exploration of the consuming power of sexual and emotional love between a man and a woman.’ Sorry for the confusion. I’ve adjusted the offending sentence. My note-taking needs improving, but there were so many good points being mentioned it was hard to keep up! John.
Heaves, don’t apologise, I’m so grateful when people who get to go to these things share them through blogging!
That’s a lovely quotation from Callil:)
Thanks for this report John … would love to have been there (though I did go to a poetry book launch this evening which was a consolation). I wrote the Wikipedia articles on Marjorie Barnard, Flora Eldershaw and M. Barnard Eldershaw … though I have yet to read A house is built which is on my TBR. I had great fun researching them … they were amazing women. I have read The persimmon tree and other stories twice and would happily read it again. They didn’t talk about Katharine Susannah Prichard? A house is built shared the 1928 Bulletin prize with Coonardoo.
I dipped into Exiles at home a lot when I was researching writers for Wikipedia but it’s one Aussie lit book I don’t have … you’ve reminded me that I should look for it in second hand shops.
I really enjoyed Amy Witting … though haven’t read her since blogging. She was, as I recollect, another late bloomer (but you could correct me on this!)
Anyhow, won’t ramble (more) … but thanks for this great report.
Thanks for adding to it, Sue. Both Geordie and Jane had others they wanted to talk about, but as is so often the case with these things there is never enough time (and always a few minutes lost at the start with introductions and the like, talking about the Stella Prize, which I think everyone in the audience was probably aware of, but it’s all part of the publicity I guess). There were a couple of late bloomers mentioned, but I couldn’t keep up with my note-taking to keep a track of them! John
On Wed, Dec 5, 2012 at 11:48 PM, Musings of a Literary Dilettante's
It’s hard to take notes and take everything in, isn’t it? And yet if I don’t take notes I forget what I have taen in!!
Thanks for your write-up, John. I love hearing both Jane and Geordie speak, they’re both knowledgeable, enthusiastic and articulate, so I’m sad to have missed this! A Melbourne version would be great. I read about M Barnard Eldershaw in The Burning Library, and I’m so keen to read Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow. It sounds right up my alley. After reading Richard Mahony this year I’m also very intrigued by Jane’s thoughts on Maurice Guest. Cheers again, Angela.
You’re welcome, Angela. I enjoyed your reflections on *Mahony. *Ah, so many Aussie classics to read, so little time… Cheers, John.
On Thu, Dec 6, 2012 at 4:07 PM, Musings of a Literary Dilettante's
Maybe we should ask the Wheeler Centre to invite them for a session?
I think that’s a great idea. I’ve contacted the good folk at Sydney Writers’ Festival to suggest something similar.
PS: you could chair it, Lisa!
I could certainly be an usher LOL
[…] of this event by John from Musings of a Literary Dilettante who was also there but unlike me, wrote it up […]